Buyers Aren’t Saying No — They’re Saying Nothing

Reading Time: 4 minutes

There was a time when rejection came clearly. “Not now.” “Wrong fit.” “We’ve gone with someone else.” Today, the most common response to outreach is no response at all. Buyers aren’t pushing back — they’re quietly disappearing. Not because they’re uninterested, necessarily, but because they’re mentally exhausted by the rhythm and tone of most sales communication. And they’ve learned that the easiest way to avoid pressure is not to resist it, but to disengage before it begins.

This behaviour has a name in broader business culture: quiet quitting. And in sales, it’s showing up as silent opt-outs. According to a 2023 HubSpot report, 65% of buyers say they ignore sales emails simply because they “don’t feel relevant.” But relevance isn’t just about content — it’s about context. And most outreach fails not because it’s wrong, but because it’s forgettable. The buyer doesn’t feel anything when they read it. They don’t object. They just move on.

This creates a new kind of problem for sellers. Objections are tangible. They give you something to work with. Silence gives you nothing. No resistance. No roadmap. Just an inbox full of unanswered messages and a pipeline full of false hope. And yet, most sales motions are still designed to respond to resistance, not indifference. That’s where the disconnect begins.

The Illusion of Activity: Why More Touchpoints Make It Worse

Faced with silence, many sales teams lean into what feels logical: increase the volume. Add steps to the sequence. Touch the prospect ten, twelve, fifteen times. Automation makes this easy. Personalisation tokens give the illusion of effort. But it’s an illusion buyers can spot a mile off. As LinkedIn’s State of Sales report found, only 8% of B2B decision-makers consider the salespeople they interact with “very effective” at understanding their business.

That’s not a problem of laziness — it’s a problem of sameness. When every message sounds like it’s come from the same playbook, buyers stop paying attention. It’s not that your outreach is bad. It’s that it’s indistinguishable. And when something is indistinguishable, it becomes disposable.

This is where sales fatigue sets in. Not just from your outreach, but from the dozen other sellers who sent something similar that day. One McKinsey study showed that enterprise buyers are now interacting with an average of ten channels before making a purchase. Your email or call is competing not just with other vendors, but with marketing content, peer recommendations, and internal initiatives that feel more urgent. If your message doesn’t rise above the noise, it adds to it. And that makes it even easier to ignore.

How to Create Contrast: Relevance, Surprise and the End of Lazy Personalisation

So how do you cut through in a world where buyers are primed to delete, dismiss, or simply ghost? The short answer is contrast. The longer answer is: you have to become more interesting than the dozens of other priorities competing for their time. That doesn’t mean louder. It doesn’t mean gimmicky. It means sharper thinking and more honest effort.

The first step is to stop faking personalisation. Buyers are not fooled by a first name tag and a mention of their company’s funding round. True relevance comes from insight. From demonstrating that you understand not just what they do, but how they think. That might mean referencing a strategic initiative from a shareholder report. Or connecting the dots between a recent leadership change and an emerging challenge. These are things a bot can’t do convincingly yet. Which is precisely the point. In a sea of automated outreach, actual human effort stands out.

Second, use the power of surprise. Not in the form of cheap tricks, but by asking questions they haven’t heard before. Don’t open with “what keeps you up at night.” Try and get the buyer to think differently through the way you ask questions — not by probing for pain, but by prompting new perspective. Ask things that challenge their assumptions, that reframe their priorities, that make them pause not because they’re defensive, but because they’ve never been asked that before. That moment of pause is where trust starts. Not because you’ve uncovered a need, but because you’ve created clarity.

Redefining the Close: Why Attention is the Real Conversion Metric

We’re used to measuring success by meetings booked or deals closed. But before either of those, there’s a more fundamental milestone: attention. Not clicks, not opens — real mental engagement. In the era of sales fatigue, attention is the currency. And it’s in short supply. As Forrester noted in their 2024 B2B Buying Study, 70% of buyers say they’re more selective about who they give time to than they were two years ago.

So what does that mean for modern sales teams? It means your outbound motion needs a rethink. It’s no longer enough to train for objection handling — you need to train for interest generation. Instead of teaching reps how to push deals forward, teach them how to make buyers stop and think. That’s what earns the reply. That’s what earns the meeting. Not pressure. Not persistence. But relevance, resonance, and respect.

And it means rethinking your pipeline. Instead of measuring volume of outreach, measure the quality of engagement. Who’s actually replying? Who’s forwarding your content internally? Who’s connecting with you on LinkedIn after your email lands? These are the new leading indicators. Not because they guarantee a close — but because they show you’re no longer being ignored.

Because in this market, silence doesn’t mean you’re doing nothing wrong. It means you’re not doing enough right.